Skip to content

How scores work

What the number in the diamond means, and what I weigh before giving a score.

The scale

  1. 9–10: Must-play

    Defines the year. Worth it even outside your favorite genre.

  2. 7–8.9: Great

    Has flaws, but worth your time and money.

  3. 5–6.9: Average

    Fun for genre fans. Everyone else can wait for a sale.

  4. 3–4.9: Weak

    The problems outweigh what works.

  5. 0–2.9: Avoid

    Not recommended, even for free.

A score, not an average

The score sums up the whole experience. The per-criterion bars show strengths and weaknesses, but the final score is not their math.

I only score what I finished

Scored reviews come from finishing the campaign or watching the whole movie. The platform I played on is listed in the details box.

Not every post has a score

News, lists, guides and opinion pieces have no diamond. Only reviews get a score.

Scores aren't for sale

Review keys and press screenings do not buy the score. Provided products and paid posts are always labeled "Sponsored content".

What if the game changes later?

The review covers the version I played. If a big update changes the experience, the post gets an "Updated on" note explaining what changed.

Full partnership policy